Carrier Contact Directory

Manage your account, file a claim, or pay a bill directly on your insurance carrier's website. You may need to create an online account if you haven't already.

Auto-Owners Insurance

1-800-346-0346

Berkshire Hathaway Guard Insurance

1-800-673-2465

Celina Insurance Group

1-800-552-5181

Central Insurance Companies

419-238-1010

Cincinnati Insurance Companies

1-888-242-8811

CNA Surety Corporation

1-800-331-6053

Dairyland (Sentry)

1-855-678-1298

Donegal Insurance Group

412-366-2633

Foremost Insurance

1-800-532-4221

Goodville Mutual Casualty Company

717-354-4921

Grand River Insurance

248-519-2390

Grange Insurance Group

1-800-422-0550

Harleysville Insurance Company (Part of Nationwide)

1-800-338-8301

The Hartford

1-860-547-5000

Hastings Insurance

330-686-6566

Homesite Insurance

1-800-947-0713

Illinois Casualty Company

309-793-1700

Liberty Mutual

1-800-290-8711

Merchants Insurance Group

1-800-462-8182

Millers Mutual Group, Inc.

717-232-3211

National General - An Allstate Company

1-888-325-1190

Nationwide

1-877-669-6877

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

1-800-686-3011

Pike Mutual Insurance Company (1859 Mutual)

330-345-2005

Progressive Insurance

1-888-671-4405

Safeco Insurance

1-800-332-3226

Selective Insurance

1-888-974-7400

State Auto Insurance Companies

1-833-724-3577

Travelers Insurance

1-800-842-5075

Trexis Insurance

1-877-384-7466

Utica First Insurance Company

1-800-456-4556

Utica National Insurance Company

1-800-598-8422

Wayne Mutual Insurance

330-345-8100

Westfield Insurance

1-800-243-0210

Western Reserve Group

1-800-362-0426